I watched the Witch and I didn’t like it. 2/5
–
The Witch, directed by Robert Eggers and released in 2015, is a film that garnered critical acclaim and divided audiences with its atmospheric and unsettling take on the horror genre. While the film boasts impressive production values and a committed cast, its slow pacing, lack of narrative clarity, and unsatisfying conclusion make it a disappointing and frustrating viewing experience.
One of the film’s strengths lies in its visual and technical aspects. The Witch is meticulously crafted, with attention to detail in its period setting and authentic language. The cinematography by Jarin Blaschke captures the bleakness and isolation of the New England wilderness, creating a foreboding atmosphere. The film’s score, composed by Mark Korven, further enhances the eerie ambiance, adding to the sense of dread.
The performances in The Witch are commendable, particularly from Anya Taylor-Joy as Thomasin, the film’s young protagonist. Taylor-Joy delivers a convincing and nuanced portrayal, effectively capturing the character’s vulnerability and strength. The rest of the cast also gives solid performances, contributing to the overall sense of unease and paranoia that permeates the film.
However, The Witch falters in its storytelling and execution. The film’s slow pacing may test the patience of some viewers, as it takes a significant amount of time for the tension to build. While slow-burn horror can be effective, The Witch’s deliberate pacing often feels tedious rather than suspenseful. The lack of a clear narrative focus and a meandering plot contribute to the film’s frustrating and disjointed nature.
Furthermore, The Witch suffers from a lack of clarity in its storytelling. The film introduces intriguing themes and ideas related to religious fervor and the fear of the unknown, but fails to fully explore or develop them. The narrative becomes muddled and ambiguous, leaving many questions unanswered and resulting in a frustrating viewing experience. While ambiguity can be effective in horror films, The Witch’s lack of resolution feels more like a missed opportunity than an intentional choice.
The climax and conclusion of The Witch are particularly underwhelming. The buildup of tension and suspense throughout the film leads to a final act that feels anticlimactic and lacks a satisfying payoff. The resolution leaves the audience with more questions than answers, further contributing to the sense of dissatisfaction and confusion.
While The Witch may be appreciated for its atmospheric and stylistic elements, it ultimately falls short in delivering a satisfying and engaging horror experience. Its slow pacing, lack of narrative clarity, and unsatisfying conclusion make it a frustrating and underwhelming film. While it may have its admirers, The Witch earns a disappointing 2 out of 5 rating. It is a film that promises much but fails to deliver on its potential, leaving audiences wanting more.