I watched Nightmare Alley and I liked it. 3/5
–
Guillermo del Toro‘s “Nightmare Alley” plunges audiences into a murky world of deception, ambition, and the sinister allure of the unknown. This neo-noir psychological thriller is a departure from del Toro’s signature fantastical style, showcasing his versatility as a filmmaker.
The film’s greatest strength lies in its impeccable ensemble cast. Bradley Cooper, in the lead role of Stanton Carlisle, delivers a tour de force performance that captures the character’s transformation from a cunning carny to a suave manipulator. His portrayal is both charismatic and chilling, embodying the dual nature of his character’s ambition.
Cate Blanchett, as the enigmatic psychiatrist Lilith Ritter, exudes an aura of mystery and intelligence. Her scenes with Cooper are a mesmerizing dance of wit and manipulation, as they spar for dominance in a battle of minds. Blanchett’s commanding presence elevates the tension and intrigue, leaving the audience perpetually on edge.
The supporting cast, including Toni Collette, Willem Dafoe, and Rooney Mara, deliver memorable performances that enrich the film’s tapestry of characters. Collette brings a visceral intensity to her role as the shrewd carnival performer, while Dafoe exudes a menacing gravitas as the carnival’s enigmatic leader. Mara, in a more subdued yet pivotal role, infuses the narrative with a haunting vulnerability.
Del Toro’s direction is characterized by its meticulous attention to detail and a visual palette that luxuriates in shadows and textures. The film’s production design, set against the backdrop of a Depression-era carnival, immerses viewers in a world of faded glamour and seedy allure. The use of practical effects and period-accurate details adds authenticity to the film’s evocative atmosphere.
The narrative, based on William Lindsay Gresham’s 1946 novel of the same name, unravels in a non-linear fashion, inviting viewers to navigate a complex web of deception and moral ambiguity. Del Toro’s screenplay, co-written with Kim Morgan, offers a layered exploration of the human psyche and the lengths to which individuals will go in pursuit of power and self-preservation.
However, “Nightmare Alley” is not without its flaws. The film’s deliberate pacing, while effective in building tension, may test the patience of some viewers. At over two and a half hours, the narrative occasionally meanders, with certain scenes feeling more protracted than necessary. This, coupled with the film’s somber tone, may prove to be a demanding viewing experience for those seeking a more briskly-paced thriller.
Additionally, the film’s intricate plot and morally ambiguous characters may alienate some viewers who prefer more straightforward narratives. The morally grey terrain explored by the characters can be challenging to navigate, and the absence of clear-cut heroes or villains may leave some audiences yearning for a more conventional resolution.
In conclusion, “Nightmare Alley (2021)” is a dark, cerebral thriller that showcases del Toro’s ability to navigate the shadowy depths of human nature. Anchored by stellar performances and impeccable production design, the film is a visually stunning descent into a world of moral ambiguity and psychological intrigue. While its deliberate pacing and morally complex characters may not resonate with all audiences, those willing to embark on this cerebral journey will find themselves rewarded by a film that lingers in the shadows of the mind long after the credits roll.