I watched May December and I didn’t like it. 2/5
–
In Todd Haynes’ latest venture, “December Romance,” he ventures into the intricate web of a controversial relationship dynamic. The film dares to explore the power dynamics entangled in the romance between an aging actress and a young man she once mentored, sparking conversations about consent, manipulation, and the blurred boundaries of desire and obsession.
At its core, “December Romance” orbits around Gracie Atherton (Julianne Moore), an acclaimed yet fading actress known for her unconventional choices. When Elizabeth Berry (Natalie Portman), an ambitious young actress, approaches Gracie to prepare for a film based on her tumultuous past relationship with a much younger man, Joe Castleman (Charles Melton), the narrative unfolds into a captivating exploration. As Elizabeth delves deeper into Gracie’s memories, reality intertwines with dramatized versions, compelling both women to confront uncomfortable truths about their desires and motivations.
While the premise is enticing and the performances commendable, the film falters in its execution. Haynes employs his trademark visual storytelling, infusing the narrative with dreamlike sequences and an eerie atmosphere. Moore’s portrayal of the enigmatic Gracie is captivating, oscillating between vulnerability and manipulation with unsettling ease. Portman equally captivates as the ambitious Elizabeth, whose curiosity morphs into an unsettling obsession. However, the characters remain frustratingly enigmatic, obscuring their true motivations and desires.
Despite its intriguing premise, “December Romance” struggles to maintain momentum. The pacing feels sluggish, with extended periods devoid of the dramatic impact promised by the premise. The exploration of the controversial relationship, initially provocative, devolves into exploitation rather than enlightenment. The ambiguity surrounding the characters’ intentions leaves viewers emotionally distant and disengaged.
Ultimately, “December Romance” feels like a missed opportunity. While it boasts an intriguing premise and strong performances, it fails to deliver a profound exploration of its themes. The film’s provocative subject matter remains underexplored, overshadowed by stylistic flourishes. Viewers are left questioning the purpose and impact of the film, feeling more unsettled than emotionally invested.
Specific shortcomings contribute to the film’s lower rating, including its surface-level exploration of complex themes, uneven tone, underdeveloped subplots, and overly ambiguous ending. While “December Romance” deserves credit for its ambition, it falls short in execution. For viewers seeking a truly thought-provoking and emotionally engaging exploration of complex relationships, this film may leave them wanting more.