I watched Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark and I didn’t like it. 2/5
–
Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark (2010) attempts to reimagine the classic made-for-TV horror film of the same name. Directed by Troy Nixey and produced by Guillermo del Toro, the film seeks to bring a modern sensibility to the tale of sinister creatures lurking in the shadows. However, despite its potential, the film falls short of delivering the truly chilling experience it promises.
One of the film’s redeeming qualities lies in its visual craftsmanship. The gothic mansion that serves as the primary setting is a character in itself, exuding an air of decay and malevolence. The production design effectively captures the oppressive atmosphere, using intricate set pieces and dim lighting to evoke a sense of foreboding. Additionally, the design of the malevolent creatures is suitably grotesque, invoking a primal fear of the unknown.
Katie Holmes, playing Kim, the female lead, gives a serviceable performance, balancing a protective instinct with genuine concern for her stepdaughter Sally (Bailee Madison). Holmes brings a degree of empathy to her role, effectively conveying the complexities of a character thrust into a sinister situation. Similarly, Bailee Madison delivers a convincing portrayal of a young girl grappling with unimaginable horrors. The chemistry between the two leads adds depth to their relationship, offering a relatable anchor amid the supernatural events.
However, where Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark falters is in its execution of horror. Despite the promising premise, the film struggles to maintain a consistently tense and unsettling atmosphere. It frequently resorts to cheap jump scares, relying on sudden loud noises and startling visuals rather than genuine psychological terror. This over-reliance on shock value diminishes the impact of the film’s more genuinely frightening moments.
The narrative also suffers from pacing issues. The first act takes too long to establish the ominous tone, with the central threat remaining largely unseen. Once the malevolent creatures are revealed, the film gains momentum, but it struggles to sustain the tension throughout. Some scenes feel drawn out, while others lack the urgency needed to maintain engagement.
Character development is another area where the film falls short. While Kim and Sally receive some depth, the supporting characters remain largely one-dimensional. Guy Pearce’s character, Alex, Kim’s boyfriend, is particularly underserved, given his potential to add complexity to the dynamic. The lack of fully fleshed-out secondary characters hampers the viewer’s investment in the overall narrative.
In conclusion, Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark (2010) falls short of delivering the truly chilling horror experience it promises. While it boasts impressive visual craftsmanship and competent performances, it struggles with an overreliance on jump scares and pacing issues. Despite its potential, the film ultimately fails to sustain the tension and unease needed to make it a standout in the horror genre.