Let me start by saying that Borderlands is not the cinematic apocalypse many have painted it to be. Is it a mess? Absolutely. But it’s a vibrant, occasionally entertaining mess that, despite its flaws, manages to offer some fun—especially if you’re a fan of the video game series or just in the mood for a flashy sci-fi romp.
A Star-Studded Cast in a Disjointed Narrative
The film boasts an impressive ensemble: Cate Blanchett as Lilith, Kevin Hart as Roland, Jack Black voicing Claptrap, Jamie Lee Curtis as Dr. Patricia Tannis, and Ariana Greenblatt as Tiny Tina. Blanchett, in particular, brings a surprising depth to Lilith, portraying her with a mix of grit and vulnerability that hints at a richer backstory. Her performance is a standout, offering a glimpse into what the film could have been with a more cohesive script.
However, the narrative is where Borderlands falters. The plot—centered around a ragtag group’s quest to find a missing girl on the chaotic planet of Pandora—is muddled and often feels like a series of disjointed set pieces rather than a coherent story. The film’s numerous rewrites and reshoots are evident, leading to tonal inconsistencies and underdeveloped character arcs.
Visuals That Pop, Humor That Flops
Visually, Borderlands is a treat. The film captures the game’s distinctive cel-shaded aesthetic, with vibrant colors and imaginative set designs that bring Pandora to life. The action sequences are dynamic, and the special effects are generally impressive, contributing to the film’s overall entertainment value.
Unfortunately, the humor doesn’t land as effectively. The film tries to emulate the game’s quirky, irreverent tone but often misses the mark. Jokes feel forced, and comedic timing is off, leading to awkward moments that detract from the viewing experience. Jack Black’s Claptrap, intended as comic relief, comes across as more irritating than amusing, and Kevin Hart’s Roland lacks the charisma needed to carry his role.
A Mixed Bag of Performances
While Blanchett shines, other performances are a mixed bag. Jamie Lee Curtis’s Dr. Tannis is underutilized, and the film doesn’t fully explore her character’s eccentricities. Ariana Greenblatt’s Tiny Tina brings energy to the screen, but her character’s development feels rushed. The ensemble cast has potential, but the script doesn’t give them enough to work with, resulting in performances that range from serviceable to forgettable.
A Flawed but Entertaining Adaptation
Borderlands is far from perfect. Its narrative issues and inconsistent tone prevent it from being a standout in the video game adaptation genre. However, it’s not without its merits. The film’s visual flair, action sequences, and Blanchett’s performance provide enough entertainment to make it worth a watch for fans of the franchise or those seeking a lighthearted sci-fi adventure.
In the end, Borderlands is a chaotic, colorful mess that almost works. It’s a film that had the potential to be great but settles for being merely okay. If you can overlook its flaws, there’s some fun to be had—but don’t expect a masterpiece.