I watched Posse and I didn’t like it. 2/5
–
Posse, released in 1993 and directed by Mario Van Peebles, is an ambitious Western that attempts to tackle themes of racism, justice, and identity within the framework of the genre. While the film showcases some commendable performances and touches upon important social issues, it ultimately falls short in its execution, resulting in a disjointed and uneven experience.
The film follows the story of Jesse Lee (played by Mario Van Peebles), a former Buffalo Soldier who returns to his hometown after the Spanish-American War. Seeking revenge against his corrupt and racist former commander, Colonel Graham (played by Billy Zane), Jesse assembles a group of outlaws and forms a posse to confront the Colonel and his gang.
One of the film’s strengths lies in its performances. Mario Van Peebles delivers a solid portrayal of Jesse Lee, displaying charisma and intensity in his role as the film’s protagonist. Additionally, Stephen Baldwin stands out as Little J, Jesse’s loyal sidekick, bringing a touch of humor and energy to the narrative. The chemistry between the actors adds some depth to their characters’ relationships, making their camaraderie somewhat believable.
Posse attempts to explore complex themes of racism and identity, shedding light on the experiences of African Americans in the Wild West. The film touches upon the racial dynamics of the time, addressing issues such as prejudice, discrimination, and the struggle for justice. It also incorporates elements of Western mythology and folklore, attempting to create a unique blend of genres. While these themes and ideas are promising, the execution feels muddled and underdeveloped.
One of the film’s major shortcomings lies in its narrative structure. The plot jumps between different timelines and locations without providing sufficient context or coherent transitions, resulting in a disjointed and confusing storytelling experience. The lack of focus and clarity undermines the impact of the film’s themes and prevents the audience from fully engaging with the characters and their struggles.
Another notable flaw is the film’s inconsistent tone. Posse attempts to balance elements of drama, action, and comedy, but the shifts between these tones are often abrupt and jarring. The comedic moments, in particular, feel forced and out of place, detracting from the film’s more serious themes and undermining the overall cohesiveness of the narrative.
The film’s production values are average at best. While some of the action sequences are well-choreographed and visually engaging, the overall cinematography and set design lack the polish and grandeur typically associated with Western films. The dialogue, at times, feels clichéd and uninspired, failing to capture the depth and nuance required to fully explore the film’s themes.
Furthermore, the character development in Posse is lacking. Many of the supporting characters are underdeveloped and fail to leave a lasting impression. Their motivations and backstories are often shallow and predictable, making it difficult for the audience to form a meaningful connection with them.
In conclusion, Posse falls short of its potential to be a thought-provoking and impactful Western film. While it showcases some commendable performances and attempts to tackle important social issues, the film suffers from a disjointed narrative, inconsistent tone, and underdeveloped characters. Despite its ambitious aspirations, Posse fails to deliver a cohesive and engaging experience. As a result, it is likely to leave viewers feeling unsatisfied and disappointed.